Nexus (Yuval Noah Harari)
Verdict: Buy, once I can set aside time to read it without interruptions.
My take: An interesting discussion of how the same information can be viewed differently depending on the viewer's history and goals, and of the "naive view" that more information will always create a better society. The sample is great, if long, and I'm interested in buying the book even though I'm only 26% of the way through it. I'll want to make sure I can read at length without interruptions, or the book might never be fully read. I also can't yet tell whether the "naive view" is a straw man, as one critic argues, so I'm trying to read as a skeptic while I learn. Sadly, I'm naive! 😄
What others say:
- Agree: Ray Hecht called it probably Harari's best book since Sapiens, and Samuel Wells in The Christian Century called it awesome and visionary.
- Disagree: The Guardian's Steven Poole called Harari a master of the sententious generalization and argued the "naive view" becomes something of a straw man. The Federal also found sweeping generalizations and overstated claims about AI.
- Worth knowing: At 528 pages it's long. One blogger called it long and slow, and suggested readers interested in where AI is heading can skip to Part II on page 191.
Bottom line: Big-picture and provocative; fans call it vital, while critics question its rigor.
Comments
Post a Comment