Proto: How One Ancient Language Went Global (Laura Spinney)

 Verdict: Skip.

My take: I struggled to enjoy this one. The writing felt boring, and I can't tell whether that's because I already knew much of the introduction and first chapter, or because the book is simply long-winded. I feel bad about it: it's clear Spinney spent a lot of time on it, and we even share a first name! I tried several times to get into the sample, but I gave up at 28%. I'm skipping this book.

What others say:

  • Agree: A NetGalley reader found the writing a bit dry in places, and some Goodreads reviewers called it disappointing, saying it has less linguistics than the subject suggests. Bookmarks calls it a good starting point for newcomers to the subject, which could explain a lukewarm reaction from readers who already know the basics.
  • Disagree: According to the author's site, the Guardian, New Statesman, and Prospect named it a book of the year for 2025. ArtsHub said she writes with clarity and momentum, in a vivid and accessible way.
  • Worth knowing: A reader's blog says the first two of eight chapters cover the origins, with the other six following individual language branches. Your sample covered the part most likely to overlap with what you already know.

Bottom line: Skip it if you already know the basics; it looks like a better fit for newcomers to historical linguistics.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Retirement Planning Guidebook Chapters 10 - 13

Another Go at Books

Retirement Planning Guidebook Chapters 4 - 6