Posts

Nexus (Yuval Noah Harari)

  Verdict: Buy, once I can set aside time to read it without interruptions. My take: An interesting discussion of how the same information can be viewed differently depending on the viewer's history and goals, and of the "naive view" that more information will always create a better society. The sample is great, if long, and I'm interested in buying the book even though I'm only 26% of the way through it. I'll want to make sure I can read at length without interruptions, or the book might never be fully read. I also can't yet tell whether the "naive view" is a straw man, as one critic argues, so I'm trying to read as a skeptic while I learn. Sadly, I'm naive! 😄 What others say: Agree: Ray Hecht called it probably Harari's best book since Sapiens , and Samuel Wells in The Christian Century called it awesome and visionary. Disagree: The Guardian's Steven Poole called Harari a master of the sententious generalization and argu...

It Can't Happen Here (Sinclair Lewis)

  Verdict: Buy. My take: This is a work of fiction written in 1935, with disturbing ties to current events. Lewis pulls you in immediately and sets up the characters well, letting readers feel disdain and disgust for many of them. I'm looking forward to reading the book itself, and it will certainly go on the buy pile. What others say: Agree: A Chicago Tribune review argued that many of the ingredients for Lewis's story were already present in 1935, and one longtime reader first read it about 50 years ago and has reread it several times since. Disagree: Time's 1935 review said Lewis couldn't make his characters live, and Britannica notes critics found the book lacking in subtlety and written too quickly. An independent bookseller cautions that comparisons between today's America and Nazi Germany are more evocative than accurate. Worth knowing: Reviewers split on tone. Bryan Alexander found it far funnier than expected, while another blogger wished for mo...

Excellent Advice for Living (Kevin Kelly)

  Verdict: Skip. My take: The sample is just snippets of advice, with no further expounding and no stories, only the statements. They're good, but not what I want. I hoped for more behind each one. It feels silly to complain about the opposite of what bothered me in The Book of Beautiful Questions , which had few questions per section and a lot of explaining. I remember enjoying Tim Ferriss's Tools of Titans a few years ago, so maybe I just want something in the middle. I'm skipping this one. What others say: Agree: A newsletter writer at The Reading Life called the criticism that Kelly offers little context fair, and wrote his own expansions on 17 of the aphorisms. A Hardcover reader felt the audiobook was like listing typical quotes and proverbs. Disagree: Kirkus gave it a starred review and joked that people will keep stealing it out of your bathroom. A blogger finished it in three sittings and found it fun, useful, and worth rereading. Worth knowing: The book ...

Proto: How One Ancient Language Went Global (Laura Spinney)

  Verdict: Skip. My take: I struggled to enjoy this one. The writing felt boring, and I can't tell whether that's because I already knew much of the introduction and first chapter, or because the book is simply long-winded. I feel bad about it: it's clear Spinney spent a lot of time on it, and we even share a first name! I tried several times to get into the sample, but I gave up at 28%. I'm skipping this book. What others say: Agree: A NetGalley reader found the writing a bit dry in places, and some Goodreads reviewers called it disappointing, saying it has less linguistics than the subject suggests. Bookmarks calls it a good starting point for newcomers to the subject, which could explain a lukewarm reaction from readers who already know the basics. Disagree: According to the author's site , the Guardian, New Statesman, and Prospect named it a book of the year for 2025. ArtsHub said she writes with clarity and momentum, in a vivid and accessible way. Worth...

The Book of Alchemy (Suleika Jaouad)

  Verdict: Defer until Dec 25, 2026, then buy it and start a 100-day journal. My take: I picked this sample thinking it was about science. It isn't. The subtitle gives it away: it's a creative-writing guide built around a 100-day journal, where you respond to daily prompts. Jaouad leans heavily into her feelings, and as an INTJ, heavy on the T, I caught myself rolling my eyes. Still, her story was compelling enough that I finished the sample. I've wanted to try another round of daily writing, and this looks like a good structure for it. I might even find some feelings worth jotting down. I'll buy it for Christmas and start then. What others say: Agree: A journaling-workshop leader on Substack said the essays and prompts mostly landed flat for her, though she expects others will love them. Disagree: Publishers Weekly gave it a starred review , and Girls Write Now called it an excellent introduction to journaling for beginners. It averages about 4.3 on Goodreads . W...

Every Tool's a Hammer (Adam Savage)

  Verdict: Buy. Strong recommendation. My take: Adam has written a fantastic book, part biography and part advice for creative people who want to be set free. In classic Adam fashion, he writes as excitedly as he speaks, always engaging and humorous. It's a good sign when you reach the end of the sample and are disappointed that there's no more to read. I'm looking forward to reading this one in full. What others say: Agree: Booklist said creators of every stripe will find it inspiring and informative, while MythBusters fans will enjoy his making misadventures. An Everand reviewer said his passion for making comes through with the same enthusiasm he had on the show. Disagree: A Cannonball Read reviewer felt his energy doesn't translate to print, that the book can't decide whether it's memoir, how-to, or self-help, and that the anecdotes feel half-told. Another blogger warned that readers wanting a traditional autobiography might be disappointed. Worth kn...

The Photonic Effect (Mike Chen)

Verdict: Buy. My take: An excellent intro. How would you feel after finally finishing your exciting and dangerous space mission, only to find your home system engulfed in civil war, and that your side might not be the noble one you hoped it was when you left years ago? The sample delivers great character building and plenty of action to draw you in early. I'm certainly buying this one. What others say: Agree: Utopia State of Mind compared it to a great Star Trek episode, with action, ethics, and plenty of twists, and Publishers Weekly praised its worldbuilding. Disagree: Reactor's reviewer felt the characters change less dynamically than hoped, and another blogger felt it borrows pieces of other stories and left them not caring. Goodreads readers average about 3.65 across 131 ratings. Worth knowing: Reactor says the full book favors the quieter side of space travel over flashy lasers and pitched battles, so expect more crew drama than the opening's action. Bottom...

The Book of Beautiful Questions (Warren Berger)

  Verdict: Skip. My take: I had high hopes for this one, but the sample was too slow. It only reached the intro questions and the first three questions in Part 1, and getting there took about 30 pages with no epiphanies. Berger would propose a small handful of questions, then pull in a lot of other people's work to explain himself. After a while I wondered whether I'd be better off reading his source books instead. I kept hoping it would speed up; maybe it's only the first two chapters that drag. I'm skipping it. What others say: Agree: Kirkus found nothing overly challenging and called the title more elegant than the contents. A blogger felt Berger thinks his questions are more beautiful than readers will. Disagree: Kirkus also said Berger makes a good case for building questioning into work culture. Goodreads readers rate it about 4.1 across 1,100+ ratings, and getAbstract's reviewer praised it as a guide to asking the right questions at the right time. Wo...

A World Without Email (Cal Newport)

  Verdict: Defer until March 2027, after I read Deep Work . My take: I found the sample interesting and engaging. The psychology of task switching and our expectation of near-instant replies is easy to guess, but I didn't expect how constantly we switch tasks, or how few stretches of uninterrupted time most workdays hold. I enjoy the science-based style, though the book might boil down to a few core ideas. Since Newport's earlier book, Deep Work , covers related ground, I'll read it first and decide by March 2027 whether to buy this one or skip it, based on what I took from it. What others say: Agree: A Goodreads reader said it could have been an article, and one blogger called it a refresher on the thesis of Deep Work with new stories attached. Disagree: Joshua Kim expected something obvious, found it surprisingly awesome, and changed how he works. His complaint: it largely ignores status and power, since many people can't block off focus time. Worth knowing: ...

Ganbatte! The Japanese Art of Always Moving Forward (Albert Liebermann)

  Verdict: Skip. My take: I liked the sample, but the idea behind ganbatte, doing the best you can with whatever you're doing, doesn't need to stretch into a $10 book. The sample leans on lists of what a procrastinator might do versus someone who embraces ganbatte, which reminded me of Goofus and Gallant from Highlights magazine. If you're researching Japanese culture or want specific actions to try, you might enjoy it. For me, I'm skipping the book and applying ganbatte to the $10 instead. What others say: Agree: Several Goodreads reviewers found it repetitive, with one doubting that a single word can fill a whole book, and another saying it lacked depth. Disagree: Publishers Weekly called it an enjoyable debut, and a few Goodreads readers liked its lists, examples, and thought-reframing tables best. Worth knowing: The full book is 160 pages of about 50 short chapters , with "Ganbatte Rules" sprinkled in as short action steps. Bottom line: A gentle, ...